Blue Light Card has commercial relationships with brands mentioned in this article and may earn a commission if you purchase products through one of our links, at no extra cost to you.
It’s half past two on Christmas Day. Someone is guarding the roast potatoes like it’s a hostage situation, someone else has already stolen four pigs in blankets off the tray before the plates are even out, and your Great Grandad is about to announce, in front of everyone, that sprouts are a crime.
Every household has a Christmas dinner opinion, so we asked Blue Light Card members to settle a few. 413 of you got back to us about roasties, mash, sprouts, gravy and more. Here’s the verdict, with charts. Spoiler alert: gravy fans, you’re going to feel very seen.
And if you’re the one in charge of the big Christmas food shop, use your Blue Light Card to get it for less with a Shopping Card. Even a few % off a massive holiday shop makes a big difference at an expensive time of year.
Yes, we know. The results are why you’re here. But every good report starts with a bit of methodology, and we’re taking this seriously.
We surveyed 413 of our Blue Light Card members, not the whole nation. Think of it as the best debate in the break room, with better snacks.
You came from the NHS, police, ambulance and fire services, social care, education, the armed forces and more. Some groups were small, so take those bits with a pinch of salt. And if you’re passionate about where the North/South line sits, don’t take it too seriously.
Let’s start with the big one: what are the best potatoes for Christmas dinner? Roasties won, and it wasn’t even close. Almost 95% of you have roast potatoes on the plate somewhere. One NHS member was just glad someone was finally taking food questions seriously:
“Finally, some real journalism about the serious things! Come on the roasties.”

Here’s where it gets interesting. When it comes to the best potatoes, where you live matters more than anything else. In the South, 81% of members want roast potatoes only, compared to 46% in the Midlands and 37% in the North. The difference? Northerners and Midlanders are far more likely to insist on double potatoes, with mash sharing the plate.
We only had a small sample from Scotland, and an even smaller one from Wales and Northern Ireland – but we can safely say we got strong results from our potato-loving friends in the upper half of England.
What you do for work makes almost no difference to your Christmas dinner opinions. Do police officers prefer roasties to mash? No more than anyone else, so no special roastie privileges, sorry officers. The roast potato divide is about where you live, not what you do.
If you’re a devout ASDA shopper, don’t forget you can get money off your Christmas dinner with a Blue Light Card Shopping Card.
Turkey keeps the crown among traditional Christmas dinner items, although if we’re honest, it’s more of a shared throne. Count every plate where turkey turns up (alone or with company), and it’s two-thirds of the room.

Turkey loyalty also changes depending on who you ask. Fun fact: 79% of ambulance workers had turkey on the table, compared with 60% of those in education.
But turkey definitely has its critics. Some would ban it from the table completely, including this member who works for the ambulance service and is not here for a dry roast:
“Turkey is the worst Christmas dinner addition I can think of, too dry, even with lashings of gravy.”
Here’s the biggest shock of the year: more than 50% of Blue Light Card members said they love sprouts.

But they’re also the most banned food on the table, when asked. A favourite and a villain; Marmite has competition. We even acknowledged that sprouts can be delicious with a bit of flavour, as proved by a member who works for the NHS:
“Sprouts fried with bacon should be the only vegetable on the plate.”
If you’re planning to pick up your sprouts at M&S Food, get a Shopping Card first to save on the big shop. Love them or hate them, may as well get them for less.
A sensitive question because, let’s face it, pigs in blankets are a Christmas delicacy for many.

Three to four is the sweet spot, but three members admitted going all the way up to 10: one from social care, one from education and one from the ambulance service. We’re not judging. Another member explained exactly why counting is so hard:
“It is difficult to answer as so many get taken from the serving platter and diverted straight into my mouth before even reaching the plate.”
In a turn you might not have expected, Yorkshire puddings are in a similar boat to sprouts, with nearly two-thirds of the room calling them essential. Overall, Yorkshire puddings are in good company on a Christmas dinner plate with roasties and gravy.

If Sainsbury’s is where your Yorkshire puddings are coming from, grab a Shopping Card before the big shop.
After all that, a peace treaty. Roasties may divide the country, but gravy brings it back together. Only 5% of members say no to gravy at all.

That doesn’t mean you all agree on where it goes, mind. One member, who works for the NHS, is drawing a firm line:
“Gravy cannot touch the mash potato.”
And a member in social care has a rule for the mixing of sauces:
“Cauliflower cheese should not be on the same plate as gravy!”
The pudding vote was tight, but the traditional dessert edges its way onto the Christmas dinner table. 18 individuals would ban it from the table altogether, though.

The people who do say yes have strong views on how to serve it. A member, who works in social care, is firmly on one team:
“Whiskey butter rather than brandy butter.”
Meanwhile, another member who works for the NHS has some thoughts on sauce:
“Custard on Christmas pudding, not white sauce.”
If Tesco is your supermarket of choice this festive season, remember to buy a Shopping Card to help save a few pounds.
We also asked what single food you’d ban from Christmas dinner, and 397 of you gave an answer. Sprouts tied for first place with a very generous group who said they’d ban nothing at all.
Next up on the hit list: cranberry sauce, bread sauce, turkey, parsnips, cauliflower cheese, stuffing (oh, the horrors) and red cabbage. Pigs in blankets barely made the list, with just 6 votes.
We also asked for your most controversial Christmas dinner opinions, and plenty of you took it to mean “what do you do that nobody else does?” Which we love. Consider this the official collection of Christmas hot takes
Some of your Christmas dinner ideas skip the roast altogether: a curry, Chinese or pizza on the big day. Fish, steak and venison were also thrown into the mix. If you’re ordering in, it’s worth checking your Blue Light Card offers with Uber Eats, Just Eat and Deliveroo first. Fewer pots to wash up, too.
And a member who works in social care would like everyone to calm down, as some of you decided that Christmas dinner is just an overrated Sunday roast:
“It’s just a roast guys, don’t stress.”
A few of you told us the date on the calendar is more of a suggestion, especially with shift work. A member who works for the NHS volunteers for the festive shifts:
“I always volunteer to work over the festive period so my amazing A&E colleagues with children can spend this special time with their families.”
And a member who’s part of the police force has family with unique Christmas traditions:
“Don’t judge me, I’ll be at work. My lot are asking for fajitas, pigs in blankets and stuffing. I’m having no part in this as I’m working a 12-hour shift on Christmas Day!”
Whenever you celebrate and whoever’s cooking it, we hope there’s gravy.
After 413 opinions, the Christmas dinner plate is quite busy. A lot of potatoes, a respectable amount of gravy and a shopping trolley heavier than Santa’s sack.
Browse Blue Light Card Shopping Cards for a small helping hand with your big food shop this Christmas. From Sainsbury’s, Tesco, ASDA, Morrisons, M&S and Waitrose, wherever you do your food shop, you can buy a Shopping Card for less than its face value and spend it like any other gift card. Or grab a discount at Iceland or Co-op.
Try a Blue Light Card Shopping Card, which is a discounted gift card for a supermarket that you spend in store or online like any other. Writing a list before you go helps too, especially with lots of items to buy and people to please.